The Hornaday Road Report
- 1 The Hornaday Road Report
- 2 by Joe Krynock July 4, 2008
- 3 At the Recorder of Deeds Office
- 4 This is the "Phillips Manor Plan of Lots."
- 5 This is the plan that created "Revision Way" which was actually a revision to the original "Phillips Manor Plan of Lots"
- 6 This is the Rehman Family plan of lots.
- 7 Related Subjects to the "Hornaday Road Report"
The Hornaday Road Report
by Joe Krynock July 4, 2008
The first part of this is my introduction and short history of the origins of The Carrick-Overbrook Historical Society along with my first order of business was to be what I will title "The Hornaday Road Report."
At the 2007 Hornaday Road block party, John Rudiak and me were discussing our street’s historical background . This annual neighborhood gathering is where neighbors get together to renew friendships and say "Hi." Recently retired and with time on his hands, John mentioned that he was going to the Recorder of Deeds office to research deed information and since I also wanted to explore my home’s past, and to determine a build date, John and I decided to work together. As we talked more other neighbors mentioned historic information about their homes and information of our Hornaday Road neighborhood. Even with these scattered tidbits of information not many knew specific details for sure.
I told John, who didn't know much about Hornaday Road even though he lived here since 1976, that a Pittsburgh Councilman named John M. Phillips was a friend of William T. Hornaday. In fact, when they were not hunting together, they promoted stuff like Boy Scouting, better zoos and conservation.
[William T. Hornaday] was a conservationist writer but he was also a taxidermist and the director at the Bronx Zoo. Years ago I bought a bargain priced book titled “Buck Fever” because it written by Mike Sajna, now deceased, a writer that I recognized. Mike Sajna's book was printed by the University of Pittsburgh Press and it was about deer hunting and the Pennsylvania Game Commission history. In that book there were the names of John M. Phillips and William T. Hornaday. We talked about that and I stated that I wanted to investigate that small bit of information, someday soon. John noted that I was retired so now was as good a time to start as ever.
The next day after our block party I found my copy of “Buck Fever” and re-read pages 68 to 78 to refresh my memory and sure enough the clues to our history where there. Then I then suggested to John that perhaps together we could collaborate on a Hornaday Road history project and we could do a story or report for our neighbors and friends before the next year’s block party in 2008.
Parts of this story are missing, as yet. For example, why did John M. Phillips name Hornaday Road after his friend, William T. Hornaday? What happened to his cousin, John Phillips? Did he pass away at an early age?
A short time later we went to the Carrick Library searching for information. Julia Kuchta, Carrick Librarian, showed us the file cabinets in one corner of the community room. Pleasantly surprised, we found that Mr. Joe Spiecker, a local historian, along with help from Mrs. Audrey Dawida, also a Carrick historian, sorted and archived local history for close to twenty years. Joe and Audrey had assembled many binders of information and it was not touched for several years. In fact, John found a crumpled piece of paper with a Volunteer Fireman’s badge attached from when Carrick was a borough. We both felt that this item was not just rare but of great historic importance to the community, too important to just be lying in a file drawer easily lost. As we looked at the collection of photos and articles, we found missing and misplaced as to page numbers. John commented that if all this stuff was scanned and digitized it would be easier to protect, store, document and collect.
To give you an idea of what we found there were photostatic copies of old photos, some original photos, news articles and papers, loose papers all lying at the bottom of drawers, perhaps they fell out, were ransacked or they just were never identified and mounted. Joe Speiker was contacted but he said he lost interest and was in ill health at the time, but asked us to take care of his collection.
I am a carpenter by trade and computer work is not my expertise. I felt that my plan for a short historical letter to the neighbors had suddenly thrust me into much deeper waters than I had intended. John suggested that instead of making and saving copies of our findings, which would have amounted to reams of paper, that we digitize it all into a website for anyone to review, not just Hornaday residents, to explore in their own time and leisure. So it was John who took me into this new and uncharted internet territory with the website idea.
Often together and independently, we looked for maps and historical items on internet sites. I found the Historic Pittsburgh Project online and among their sources and maps was the survey map dated 1905.
At the Recorder of Deeds Office
John and I started at the Allegheny County Recorder of Deeds office downtown and we pulled dozens of dusty Deed Books to track our own property records. We spent most of a day there when John found some very interesting information about J. B. Murray's housing plan laid out in December 1859 and made copies for later reference.
And then we found this map and its information was related to all of the homes and owners in the area which raised more questions for us.
Among other details, this map shows that a John Phillips had owned a “piano” shaped piece of land which had his mansion as it faced Southern Avenue, also known as Brownsville Road, The Brownsville Plank Road, or The Brownsville Road. His property was bordered on the northern side by Becks Ave. (the township road) which was was changed by 1916 to Agnew Avenue.
This enlarged section of the 1905 map details how John Phillips’ mansion sat on Lot 3 set back from Brownsville Road or Southern Avenue and was centered where the current Hornaday Road is now. His “Governor’s style” driveway for his horse drawn carriages curved away from his home to meet the streets that we know as East Agnew Avenue and Madeline Street. We think that it may have been built about the time of the Civil War around 1863.
A close examination of the Carrick post card photo of John Phillips home, (provided by Carol Anthony of the South Pittsburgh Historical Group,) reveals a platform and a telescope pointed skyward at the center of the roof. The driveway is barely noticeable in this photo.
As the 1905 map shows, that John Phillips mansion and his property extended, east to the Rehman family property from The Southern Ave. So, at one time, before there was a “Hornaday Road” John Phillips owned an area that was eventually divided into lots for eighty homes. His mansion was on the entire flat top area which has been sub-divided since then, into forty lots (39 homes and currently named Zion Church) with those addresses from 95 to 163. This section was only a part of the "Phillips Manor Plan". The original plan included the boundaries of Rehman Street and Murray Street (now Madeline) and Scout avenue.
This is the "Phillips Manor Plan of Lots."
Those homes are on lots that were laid out in October of 1915, by John M. Phillips. In October of 1926, John M. Phillips, John Phillips’ nephew, once again laid out the Phillips Manor Plan revision, of lots 98 to 118 inclusive, in order to provide an alley way to those homes which he called Revision Way. It is estimated to have about 18 acres in all.
This is the plan that created "Revision Way" which was actually a revision to the original "Phillips Manor Plan of Lots"
I have found Carrick Borough ordinances dated 1913 that detail street name changes for all sections of the J.B.Murray area and plan. This was done in anticipation of a home building effort on Hornaday Road. I did not research individual homes as per public records for specific build dates. I think it is fair to say that there was some access to Hornaday and Dowling at that time. One resident recalls that the very lower part of Hornaday road itself was a dirt road in the 1950's, which can be seen by the old and newer style homes.
As noted Hornaday Road did not exist according to the 1905 map, though plans for our homes and lots were done by J. B. Murray in 1859. According to that 1859 map John Phillips only owned huge lots 1 thru 7. It should be easy for Hornaday residents to imagine our road thru the center of his mansion and property eastward to the slight bend and then downhill beginning at Rehman Street. In 1915 the Hornaday Road from Rehman to Dowling Street was called Waltman Street and lead down to August Waldman's farm where it met Stevenson Street renamed Dowling in 1916. Why Waltman and not Waldman? Another mystery.
On Stevenson Street nine lots were laid out by the Carrick Borough School Directors on November 19, 1915, for the third location of Concord Elementary School. These lots sit on the southside Dowling Street.
The Rihman Heirs, note spelling change to Rehman Street, laid out seven lots from Hornaday Road to Madaline Street on the eastern side of that street. Some name changes so far noticed have been due to ownership changes, but some others like Rehman from the original Rihman, may be due to pronounciation variations at that time.
This is the Rehman Family plan of lots.
Continuing the list of land owners involved with Hornaday Road at that time, we find the Bielau plan of lots beginning with addresses 201 downhill to approximately 229. The Bielau property was on the left or north side of the downhill section, with the Benarding property down to Dowling Street (note Concord school number 3 of 5 properties on lot 11.)
Bernarding owned lots adjoining these, additional odd numbered addresses 231 to 251.
Directly on the opposite, on the southern side were lots that were divided from August Waldman’s farm. In fact, this section of our road was called Waltman until several zoning changes were made in 1913. John noted that J. B. MURRAY owned this area at one time and his name is prominent in italic text on many early maps of this area.
We found that his original plan was to connect Agnew and Hornaday road with another 364 foot long section of Red Rose Avenue. This would have made all three sections of Red Rose Avenue 1,202 feet long. But that would have required eliminating 219 Hornaday Road and 217 Agnew Avenue, which are the property lots between Agnew Avenue and Hornaday Road.
Eliza Weber owned all the lots on the eastern side of Redrose Avenue. At this time 10 houses facing Redrose Avenue and perhaps four more facing Hornaday share her original property. Roughly speaking, fourteen of the 22 addresses listed on this street seem to have been built by the same builder and possibly many more in the years around 1927. There are older homes, dated from 1876,1900,1904,1907 and 1910, if county records were always correct.
Also shown on the accompanying plan of lots, William F Seiger owned approximately two acres which was divided into 14 parcels. Ten lots were on the western side of Redrose and four lots were to face Hornaday. Two homes, at 218 and 220 Hornaday were built on lots three and four. My home at 216 was built on lots one and two.
Related Subjects to the "Hornaday Road Report"
Prior to 1927 this area, was known as Carrick Borough which was at one time part of Baldwin Township. Lower Saint Clair Township is also found on some deeds. Carrick Borough by 1926 vote was officially annexed into the city of Pittsburgh in 1927. The old and narrow borough building is at 1808 Brownsville Road. Before 1927, Carrick was very progressive under the guidance of very knowledgeable and foresighted leadership. Carrick already had the first sewerage system in western Pennsylvania. Just take a short step out onto Hornaday Road to see the Carrick Boro logos on all the manholes. Here are several photos of manhole covers that John Rudiak found and photographed.
We learned from the John Heinz Historical Center that John Phillips was vice president of Oliver Iron and Steel Company, also formerly known as Lewis and Phillips on the South side at 12th street on the Monongahela River. John Phillips had a son in 1864, also named John with no middle initial. At this point in time in our investigations not much else is known about him.
John M. Phillips, mentioned previously, is our connection to William T. Hornaday. John M. Phillips was not the son but a nephew of John Phillips and was the Vice President of Oliver Iron and Steel Company. A better explanation follows and is from Mike Sajna’s book “Buck Fever.” (see pg 69)
“John MacFarlane Phillips was born February 15, 1861. He was the son of James Phillips, one of the founders of the Oliver Iron and Steel Company, whose own father had come to Western Pennsylvania from Northern Ireland in 1795 to work as a blacksmith. Phillips attended public schools and then studied engineering and was made superintendent of the bolt works and forging plants of the Lewis Oliver and Phillip’s company. Later he became manager of the company’s mining equipment department and in 1899, with his Uncle John, purchased the company’s mine supply division and established the Phillip’s mine and Mill supply company. He was that company’s President one year later (1890).”
At this point of my history search, I do not know exactly when John M. Phillips and William T. Hornaday met but I do know that he and Hornaday were hunting together in British Columbia in 1901. They were involved in many aspects of game protection and the mad rush to the west had nearly wiped out all fur bearers, most notably the buffalo and the beavers.
There are references in various news articles that John M. Phillips was married at that time and took his new bride, Harriet Duff Phillips, to a ranch, where they stayed for a month. Hornaday and Phillips were in Colorado by 1903, by 1906 Phillips was an illustrator for another of Hornaday’s many conservation minded books on of which is titled “ Campfire in the Canadian Rockies. ”
In 1907 they were in Mexico and as they had done before Hornaday and Phillips donated even more stuffed animals from their hunts for displays in Museums. At the Carnegie Museum of Natural History in Oakland at least one of Phillips’ displays remains in the hall of mammals. It is a glass enclosure displaying a family of Cheetahs. However, sharing time together can lead to common interests: zoos, conservation, camping and hunting which helped bring these men together, although there was a seven year age difference between them. Hornaday and Phillips realized that outdoor training and conservation awareness could be fostered in youth through Boy Scouting. They were not alone in their thinking and according to Mike Sajna John M. Phillips organized the First Boy Scout troop in Pennsylvania in 1910. It was the second such troop in America. Phillips provided its members with a place to meet in his home at 2336 Brownsville road. This location is now the site of Saint Piux Church and small remnants of the original “castellated” stone wall remains between the church and Concord Elementary School. In front of the Church the wall had been lowered but it returns to its original “castellated” height and location in front of the home to the right of the church. Phillips’ home was also used for the celebration of many church services until 1959 when it was demolished for the new church.
In its borough days, Carrick also had the first filtered water supply in western Pennsylvania; with 180 pounds per square inch of pressure; coming from the South Pittsburgh water plant, located at Beck’s Run Road, site of Hays Mine. Carrick Borough and its wealthy businessmen had already begun paving its streets with planks of wood three inches thick and four feet wide along with sidewalks. John M. Phillips, for the most part paid for the widening of Brownsville Road to a 60 foot right-of-way from Becks Run Road to 2331 Brownsville Road Mt Oliver.
Once annexed into the city, some street names were changed to avoid duplication of existing street names in use elsewhere in Pittsburgh. Murray Street became Madeline Street and the original bend in Murray Ave (look between Murray’s “Rs” on the 1905 map) has since been straightened. Beck’s Avenue is Agnew and was also a township road in Baldwin Township until 1927.
Take a look at The Crailo Plan, The Southern Avenue Land Company on the 1905 map, just north of Hornaday Road homes. This area was owned by John Agnew, beginning with its narrow lots on the north side of the street that still bears his name. One of my early assumptions about this area which have been proved correct is that this fifty two acre parcel of land was given to John Agnew and his wife and her father which Agnew and Chambers operated a glass works there. I contacted, Susan Buyers, an Agnew relative, to ask if Agnew and Chambers had taken over Engleart Glass, the first glass factory in Pittsburgh. She did not verify that question but if she had another early historic puzzle piece would fall into place. John Agnew’s new home, likely faced the Southern Road, AKA Brownsville Road, after looking at a drawing of that house. We think that it is located where the BP gas station is today. If Agnew also had his South Side glass factory, this older Engleart site was razed and resold in small lots, perhaps many of these new residents were employees at his South Side glass works.
The name of Engleartville was the local name of Carrick prior to 1853, when Dr. John O’Brien established the first post office naming it Carrick after his home town of Carrick-on-Suir, Tipperary County, Ireland.